The greatest thread in the history of Brewers' message boards has once again reappeared. Let the debate begin!

(I didn't even look at last years', so some might be a bit different)


Starters:

Jason Kendall - Scott0303 - Still plays, doesn't contribute as much.
Prince Fielder - jpat - Unquestioned leader, top producer.
Felipe Lopez - darklotus - New guy who has stepped it up.
JJ Hardy - me - Not as productive as he once was. Still handsome.
Craig Counsell - c3raig - Duh.
Ryan Braun - Fan - Another top producer, kinda controversial.
Mike Cameron - BrainDed - Pimp.
Corey Hart - Medic - Former All-Star. Can he get back to that form?

Bench:

Mike Rivera - RiveraMadness - Another duh.
Casey McGehee - Violent Narc - New guy too. Producing out of this world.
Mat Gamel - trwi7 - When he does play, flashes of brilliance.
Billy Hall - Tyler - Lightning rod, although we hardly see him.
Frank Cantalanotto - thirdstoolin - Pops up every now and then.
Jody Gerut - Razzy - Someone has to be. Sorry.

Rotation:

Yovani Gallardo - UWbrewball - A no-brainer. Look what he give us.
Jeff Suppan - Super Suppan - Well, No Mas, since Gagne is gone...
Braden Looper - tonyei31 - Why not?
Manny Parra - Macha Man - Stay hot, baby!
Tim Dillard - jammin481 - Can't wait to get those boobs into the rotation!

Bullpen:

Mitch Stetter - vismund - Smart guy who can be amazing.
Mark DiFelice - trouty42 - Another tough one.
Todd Coffey - bobadgers - Been around awhile, steady.
Carlos Villaneuva - Chukk - Up and down. Up and down.
Mike Burns - dusters - Beat down a bit (Fan), but still around.
Trevor Hoffman - slaket - Our lockdown guy.
RJ Swindle - Swizzul - Here off-and-on.

DL:

Rickie Weeks - FYP - Wish he was still playing everyday.
Dave Bush - adambr2 - Another smart guy who can give us a ton.
Chris Smith - miamiflashfan - Youngster. That is all.
Seth McClung - McClunger - Yet another duh.
David Riske - gobrewers2213 - We expected a lot from him, but...

Apologies to guys like biestie, thebruce, Swizzul, sausagepeteza, all the others. Too hard to do the coaching staffs/40-man roster without just making shit up.

RyGuy wrote:The greatest thread in the history of Brewers' message boards has once again reappeared. Let the debate begin!

(I didn't even look at last years', so some might be a bit different)


Starters:

Jason Kendall - Scott0303 - Still plays, doesn't contribute as much.
Prince Fielder - jpat - Unquestioned leader, top producer.
Felipe Lopez - darklotus - New guy who has stepped it up.
JJ Hardy - me - Not as productive as he once was. Still handsome.
Craig Counsell - c3raig - Duh.
Ryan Braun - Fan - Another top producer, kinda controversial.
Mike Cameron - BrainDed - Pimp.
Corey Hart - Medic - Former All-Star. Can he get back to that form?

Bench:

Mike Rivera - RiveraMadness - Another duh.
Casey McGehee - Violent Narc - New guy too. Producing out of this world.
Mat Gamel - trwi7 - When he does play, flashes of brilliance.
Billy Hall - Tyler - Lightning rod, although we hardly see him.
Frank Cantalanotto - thirdstoolin - Pops up every now and then.
Jody Gerut - Razzy - Someone has to be. Sorry.

Rotation:

Yovani Gallardo - UWbrewball - A no-brainer. Look what he give us.
Jeff Suppan - Super Suppan - Well, No Mas, since Gagne is gone...
Braden Looper - tonyei31 - Why not?
Manny Parra - Macha Man - Stay hot, baby!
Tim Dillard - jammin481 - Can't wait to get those boobs into the rotation!

Bullpen:

Mitch Stetter - vismund - Smart guy who can be amazing.
Mark DiFelice - trouty42 - Another tough one.
Todd Coffey - bobadgers - Been around awhile, steady.
Carlos Villaneuva - Chukk - Up and down. Up and down.
Mike Burns - dusters - Beat down a bit (Fan), but still around.
Trevor Hoffman - slaket - Our lockdown guy.

DL:

Rickie Weeks - FYP - Wish he was still playing everyday.
Dave Bush - adambr2 - Another smart guy who can give us a ton.
Chris Smith - miamiflashfan - Youngster. That is all.
Seth McClung - McClunger - Yet another duh.

Apologies to guys like biestie, thebruce, Swizzul, sausagepeteza, all the others. Too hard to do the coaching staffs/40-man roster without just making shit up.

Haha, I like this. Agree with every single one.

I'll be Lawrie...minus the Canuckness

YES! I have been waiting for this all year.

Bill Hall...lmao..

I should be pissed that I am relegated to the bench but my brother is a God damned starter.....but you made me Casey McGehee and I can't argue that. I've loved that guy since I saw him opening day of ST.

Here is last years lineup. I loved being Billy Hall last year.

http://miltownbrewers.com/messageboard/viewtopic.php?t=2765

Very good lineup, that's pretty sweet. I'm gonna text my bro and tell him he's BrewersCubs Jody Gerut. Maybe he'll quit working so much and start logging in again.

RyGuy wrote:JJ Hardy - me - Not as productive as he once was. Still handsome.

Made me laugh. Don't know why.

Alright, Manny Parra! I like it.

Fuck my life.

Chukks makes me laugh inside. And sweet, I didn't know my slider was so good.

Razzy wrote:Fuck my life.

HE'S BAACCCK.

Weeks! DL! I threw up in my mouth a little!

BILLY FUCKING HALL????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I like it.

Fuck you!

I give my thumbs up stamp of approval.

I guess I need to work on cutting out the fluff

I like carlos.

Razzy wrote:Fuck my life.

Maybe you should post this on that website.

T.Y.L.E.R wrote:BILLY FUCKING HALL????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I like it.

come back player of the year next year.

RyGuy wrote:Apologies to guys like biestie, thebruce, Swizzul, sausagepeteza, all the others. Too hard to do the coaching staffs/40-man roster without just making shit up.

Every year I'm snubbed....I'm used to it